December 12, 2023
Editorial Disclaimer
This content is published for general information and editorial purposes only. It does not constitute financial, investment, or legal advice, nor should it be relied upon as such. Any mention of companies, platforms, or services does not imply endorsement or recommendation. We are not affiliated with, nor do we accept responsibility for, any third-party entities referenced. Financial markets and company circumstances can change rapidly. Readers should perform their own independent research and seek professional advice before making any financial or investment decisions.
Rob was already a great coach. He showed up every week in an online community, encouraged entrepreneurs through their hardest days in business, and watched people push forward because of conversations he had with them. The only problem? He was doing it for free.
That is not an unusual place to start. Most aspiring coaches spend months, sometimes years, giving their best thinking away before they ever charge for it. The skills are there. The results are there. What is missing is the structure that turns what they are already doing into a profitable, sustainable business.
In a live coaching session on the Business Bench, Robin Waite sat down with Rob McCauley, a 38-year-old retail worker and aspiring accountability coach, and built him a complete blueprint in under an hour. This post breaks down that conversation into the exact steps coaches, consultants, and freelancers need to go from giving their time away to charging confidently for it.
If you were starting a coaching business tomorrow, what would you charge? Most new coaches land somewhere around £50 an hour. It feels fair. It feels like a reasonable starting point. Robin explains why it immediately creates a problem.
To take home £2,000 a month, a business needs to generate around £3,000 before tax (assuming 30% goes to the government). At £50 an hour, that means billing 60 client-facing hours a month, or 15 hours a week just on delivery. On paper, 15 hours sounds manageable. In practice, it leaves almost nothing for everything else the business demands.
"For most service businesses," Robin explains, "the maximum number of hours you can realistically sell in a week is 15. Those other three days are spent on marketing, sales, admin, childcare, and everything else that comes with running your own operation. You've already created a glass ceiling by charging £50 an hour."
The fix is not to work more hours. It is to change how the offer is structured entirely.
Before building a coaching package, you need to be clear on what clients are truly buying. Robin calls this the Dream Outcome, and most coaches stop one layer too shallow when they try to define it.
When Robin asked Rob what outcome his accountability coaching delivered, the first answer was self-belief. Robin pushed further. What does self-belief give them? More motivation. And what does more motivation give them? More outreach, more clients, more income.
"You usually only need to go two layers deep," Robin says. "Health, wealth, happiness, love. Those are the four pillars people are ultimately working toward. Everything else is a step on the way."
For Rob's clients, the Dream Outcome is more clients and more money. That is the transformation he is selling, and it is what gives a coaching package its real commercial value. A pricing strategy built on anything shallower than that will always underperform.
Packaging a coaching service means turning it from custom, time-based work into a repeatable, outcome-based offer with a name, a fixed duration, and a price that reflects the result. Robin calls this productising your services, and it changes everything about how the offer lands with a prospect.
The structure is simple. Take the Dream Outcome, set a fixed time period (Robin and Rob settled on 12 weeks), and attach a single fixed fee for the full transformation.
The psychology shift this creates is striking. Robin ran Rob through the comparison directly. At £50 an hour, 12 sessions costs £600. Present that to a prospective client as "£600 for three months" and it feels cheap, almost throwaway. But if that same £600 investment could help an entrepreneur add £50,000 to their top line, suddenly the maths stops working in the client's favour.
"We haven't changed the price," Robin points out. "It's still £50 an hour. But the moment you bundle it into a transformation, the perceived value is completely different."
The principle here is outcome-based pricing: the client is not paying for 12 sessions. They are paying for the result those sessions deliver.
Pricing is not just a logical calculation. Robin describes it as a head-and-heart process, and both sides have to be in agreement before a price is ready to use with clients.
The head part is the maths: income target, tax, number of clients you can serve, and a back-calculation to reach a viable price. For Rob, working backward from £3,000 a month with 2.5 clients gave a minimum price of £1,200 per programme.
The heart part is what Robin calls the Pricing Auction: a scale of numbers spoken aloud to identify the point where the price feels honest rather than either cheap or fraudulent. For Rob, that scale went £600, £800, £1,000, £1,200, £1,500. At £1,000 it felt right. At £1,200, slightly stretching. At £1,500, Rob's gut response was immediate: "I'm not worth that."
Robin's observation: "At £1,200 you're playing just outside your comfort zone. That is exactly where you want to be."
They had doubled the original price without changing the offer, the time commitment, or the number of sessions.
On payment structure, Robin advises against splitting the total into equal monthly instalments. Divide £1,200 by three and it becomes £400 a month, which repositions the offer as a subscription rather than a transformation. Instead, front-load: £600 upfront to get started, followed by two payments of £300. This anchors the client into the full programme. They are investing in an outcome, not paying as they go, and the structure reinforces that commitment.
This is the question most new coaches get stuck on. Rob put it directly: "How do you convince someone your service is worth it when you've never been paid for this before?"
Robin's answer was equally direct. "You don't convince them. You shouldn't have to."
The framework Robin uses comes from Rich Litvin's The Prosperous Coach, a four-step process that turns natural conversations into coaching clients without pressure, manipulation, or anything resembling a hard sell.
That is the full pitch. No pressure, no manufactured urgency, no convincing. A well-run diagnostic means the client typically asks what happens next before you have said a word.
Running the numbers: at £1,200 per client, Rob needs 2.5 new clients a month to hit his £3,000 target. To get 2.5 clients, he needs roughly 8-10 consultations (one in three converts). That is one or two consultations a week, which fits around any current employment or other commitments.
The temptation when starting a coaching business is to build a website, set up social media channels, and start producing content before approaching a single prospective client. Robin thinks most people get this order completely backwards.
"Sometimes the blindingly obvious approach is to go and find some of your ideal clients in real life and talk to them. There might be 50 of them at a local networking event right now."
The first step is getting specific about who the ideal client actually is. "Entrepreneurs" is broad. Entrepreneurs with ADHD is a niche. Tradespeople scaling their first business is a niche. The narrower the group, the easier it is to find where they gather and speak directly to their situation.
Once the niche is clear, the question becomes: where do they hang out? LinkedIn, professional communities, conferences, industry events, newsletters, podcasts. The goal is not to build your own audience from scratch. The goal is to show up in the spaces where your ideal clients already are.
For coaches who want to move faster, Robin describes what he calls Rocket Fuel Marketing: building partnerships with people who already have your ideal audience. He used his own appearance on Ali Abdal's channel as an example. He knew that a fraction of Abdal's audience were small business owners. One interview later, he had generated over 3,000 leads from a single piece of content.
"I focused on building partnerships with people who'd already built the audiences," Robin explains. "They've already done the hard work of building a following. Your job is to figure out how to be useful to them."
For freelancers and coaches just starting out, in-person networking is often the fastest route to first clients. Social media can come later. The first conversation that leads to a paying client is usually had in person.
Robin closed the session with a single challenge: in the next 30 days, book six consultations. Not close six clients. Not build a website. Not write a LinkedIn post. Book six consultations, run them as diagnostics, and pitch the programme at the end of each one.
"If you do that," Robin said, "I can guarantee you will get a client."
The goal is not the close. The goal is the conversation. The clients follow from the conversations.
Starting a coaching business does not require a polished brand, years of paid experience, or a social media following. What it requires is a clear offer, a price you believe in, and the willingness to go out and have real conversations with people who need what you do.
Rob's situation is not unusual. Most coaches start by giving it away for free, build confidence through those conversations, and then get stuck at the point of charging. The bridge from free to fee is not a leap of faith. It is a framework. Package the Dream Outcome, price it honestly, and use the Connect-Invite-Create-Propose process to turn conversations into clients.
Take the Fearless Business Quiz: 40 questions, free, and you will get a personalised report on exactly where your business needs to focus to grow.
Avoid charging by the hour. Instead, calculate the income you need, determine how many clients you can serve, and create a package price based on that. For example, if you need £3,000 a month and can serve 2-3 clients, a price of around £1,200 per package is a good starting point. This prices the transformation, not your time.
Create a productised service. This means defining a fixed duration, like a 12-week programme, and attaching a single fixed fee for the entire transformation. This helps clients see the value in the outcome rather than the number of sessions.
You can use a simple four-step method. First, connect with people in your niche. When you hear a problem you can solve, invite them to a consultation. In the consultation, create value by acting as a coach and diagnosing their issue. Finally, if it's a good fit, propose your programme. The process feels natural and avoids any need for convincing.
No, you don't. The fastest way to get your first clients is often by finding them where they already are, such as at local networking events or in specific online communities. Focus on having conversations first; you can build a website later.
A great goal for your first 30 days is to book a specific number of consultations, for instance, six. The focus should be on having these diagnostic conversations and making your offer, not necessarily on how many clients you sign up. The clients will naturally follow from the conversations.
