Why Social Media Marketing Doesn't Work: A New Approach to Boost Your Business

In a world where social media is often seen as the go-to marketing tool, many small business owners, especially coaches and consultants, find themselves struggling to make it work. This article explores why traditional social media marketing often fails and offers a fresh perspective on building a successful business without relying on likes and shares.

‍

The Challenges of Social Media Marketing

Social media can feel like a never-ending race. Many small business owners are caught in a cycle of posting content, hoping for quick wins. They believe that by simply sharing their services online, leads will come pouring in. However, this approach often leads to disappointment. The reality is that growing a meaningful audience takes time and effort, and many find themselves frustrated when they don’t see immediate results.

The Shift Away From Social Media

After struggling with social media for years, I decided to abandon it altogether in late 2022. This decision was pivotal. I shifted my focus from chasing likes and comments to building a hyper-engaged audience. This change led to a significant increase in my revenue and audience growth. The key was to stop getting attached to vanity metrics and instead concentrate on creating genuine connections.

Understanding Marketing Failures

To illustrate why social media often fails, I encourage you to try a simple exercise. Here’s a five-step process that highlights the disconnect between social media expectations and reality:

1. Get out your mobile phone.
2. Open your web browser (like Safari or Chrome).
3. Go to Amazon.
4. Search for "Take Your Shot" (my book).
5. Buy the Kindle version.

This exercise shows that even with clear instructions, many will struggle to complete it. This mirrors the challenges faced in social media marketing. There are numerous barriers—trust issues, technology glitches, and even simple inertia—that prevent potential customers from engaging with your content.

The Reality of Social Media Engagement

Many small business owners are shouting into the void, posting content without a clear strategy. They often create broad content to attract a wide audience, but this can dilute their message. Instead, focusing on a smaller, more engaged audience can lead to better results. You don’t need thousands of followers; even a dedicated group of a few hundred can be incredibly valuable.

Short-Term, Medium-Term, and Long-Term Strategies

To succeed in marketing, it’s essential to diversify your approach. Here’s how to break it down:

Short-Term Strategies

• Social Media: Use it to raise awareness, not necessarily to generate leads. Post consistently to keep your brand in front of potential customers.
• Paid Advertising: This can also be a short-term strategy, but be cautious of your budget. If funds run low, so do your leads.

Medium-Term Strategies

• Marketing Assets: Create content that can work for you over time, like YouTube videos, podcasts, or books. These assets can attract leads while you focus on other areas of your business.
• Engagement: Build relationships with your audience through valuable content that encourages interaction.

Long-Term Strategies

• Partnerships: Collaborate with others who have established audiences. This can provide immediate trust and access to new leads. For example, a podcast appearance can lead to thousands of new contacts.

Conclusion: A New Way Forward

If you’re tired of the social media grind, consider shifting your focus. Stop chasing likes and start building meaningful connections. By diversifying your marketing strategies into short, medium, and long-term approaches, you can create a more sustainable business model. Remember, it’s not about how many followers you have; it’s about how engaged they are. Embrace this new mindset, and you’ll likely see your business thrive in ways you never thought possible.